Free Shipping Anywhere in the US!


Your cart is currently empty.

A man hugging a woman in a field of flowers

Unique First Valentine’s Day Gifts for Your Boyfriend

A few months ago, you laughed at the seemingly far-fetched prospect of finding “the one.” Fast-forward to today and you can’t imagine doing life without your better half. Now, with Valentine’s Day coming up, you want to show him how much you appreciate him.

The trick? Not coming off as too cheesy.

The good news is that whether you’re looking for something more practical or more sentimental, a number of stellar gift options are available. And fortunately, they are all likely to fit your budget.

Here’s a rundown on the best first Valentine’s Day gifts for your boyfriend.

Custom Picture Frame

A personalized wooden picture frame is one of the best first Valentine’s Day gifts to give a boyfriend who is just as sentimental as you are. Choose a frame that you can laser-engrave both of your names onto. Then, take a romantic picture together on the big day. Afterward, your beau can add your photo to the frame to cherish forever. This gift will leave him with a memory he’ll never forget. You’ll reminisce on your first Valentine’s holiday together every time you look at the frame.

Personalized Cutting Board

Is your partner into whipping up culinary delights that tantalize your taste buds? If so, a custom cutting board may be the ideal first Valentine’s Day gift for your boyfriend. 

Perfect for a talented home chef who is a pro at slicing and chopping, a personalized cutting board can come in handy for your future date nights. Likewise, your partner can pull it out to try a spontaneous weekend recipe experiment with you. He’ll think of you every time he sees both of your names and the date you met inscribed on the board.

Choose a cutting block made of solid wood, like walnut or maple. These woods are soft, so they’ll keep your boyfriend’s favorite knives in tip-top shape while also allowing for smooth cutting.

A man and woman cooking and using cutting boards

Custom Flask

Is your boyfriend a whiskey man? If so, consider surprising him with a flask with his name on it.

Flasks make some of the best first Valentine’s Day gifts because they are extremely functional. They allow liquor connoisseurs to enjoy their favorite libations with a little privacy. And the personal touch of a custom flask makes it that much more meaningful. Look for a quality, high-end-looking flask, like one made with leatherette material. It’s a gift that is guaranteed to make your main man go “wow” when he opens the gift box.

Engraved Water Bottle

No list of the best first Valentine’s Day gifts for your boyfriend would be complete without this staple on it. 

If your boyfriend is constantly on the go and likes to stay hydrated, a custom water bottle ticks all the boxes. Look for a bottle that is insulated, as this will keep hot drinks hot and cold drinks cold. He’ll find a use for this bottle day in and day out — and he’ll never get tired of seeing his name in print each time he takes a swig.

Personalized Pocket Knife

Custom pocket knives are also some of today’s most popular first Valentine’s Day gifts. Add your guy’s name and even your own personal message to the knife. It’ll quickly become his go-to tool for everyday tasks or outdoor activities. This knife is sure to last for several years while constantly reminding your boyfriend of you.

An open pocket knife on a log

Custom Can Cooler

This is an excellent first Valentine’s Day gift for a beer-loving boyfriend. It works just as well for men who love soda. Adding your man’s initials or name to his very own can cooler will let everyone around him know two things. One, his cans will always be hands-off. And two, he’s very much loved by you.

Personalized Valet Tray

Is your man constantly losing his keys? Treat him to his very own personalized valet tray.

These trays are excellent first Valentine’s Day gifts because they make it easier for a person to organize and locate their personal possessions. Feel free to add the date you met, a quote, or your names to the tray for a special touch he’ll always appreciate.

Custom Drumsticks

Finally, if your man is a natural-born musician, surprise him with his own personalized drumsticks, complete with his name on them. These first Valentine’s Day gifts for your boyfriend just may make him tear up. After all, they’ll demonstrate to him how strongly you support his dreams and hopes.

A man sitting at a drum set with a drumstick

Find the Perfect First Valentine’s Day Gifts for Your Boyfriend at mymento Today!

At mymento, we are proud to offer a number of personalized gifts for every occasion. In addition to offering the above-listed presents, we provide custom gifts like our leather wallets, skinny tumblers, and desk nameplates.

Explore our collection of personalized items to find the perfect first Valentine’s Day gift for your boyfriend, and order today!

Share this post:

Older Post Newer Post

Leave a comment

Translation missing: